Interrupting the Silence

—

Practical spirituality in the contemplative tradition

—

Because They Are In Need – A Reflection On Matthew 25:31-46

Published by

on

Cupped hands holding white rice grains arranged in the shape of a heart

Reading the Text

Sheep on the right.
Goats on the left.

We know the drill. We’ve heard it before. It’s the judgment we’ve been told about, been threatened with, or lived in fear of.

Jesus identifies himself with the hungry, the thirsty, the stranger, the naked, the sick, the imprisoned. Whatever we do for them, he tells us, we do for him. And whatever we do not do for them, we do not do for him.

“And he will separate people one from another as a shepherd separates the sheep from the goats.” (Matthew 25:31-46)

I know which side I want to stand on, don’t you?

Sheep are the ones who fed the hungry, gave a drink to the thirsty, welcomed the stranger, clothed the naked, cared for the sick, and visited those in prison. Sometimes I’ve done that. I’ll bet you have too. Welcome to the flock.

Goats are the ones who did not feed, give a drink to, welcome, clothe, care for, or visit those in need. Sometimes I didn’t do that. Maybe you didn’t either. Welcome to the herd.

Sheep are blessed by the Father and inherit the kingdom.

Goats are accursed and dismissed into the eternal fire.

Neither the sheep nor the goats, however, recognize Jesus in what they do and what they do not do for those in need. “When was it that we saw you?” they both ask.

Misreading the Text

There are some obvious questions raised by the text:

  • Am I a sheep or a goat?
  • How much does one have to do and have I done enough?
  • What’s in it for me? Am I part of the in-flock, the blessed ones who will inherit the kingdom, or am I an accursed goat being herded to the eternal fire never to be heard from again?
  • When, where, and in whom have I seen Jesus? And where have I missed him? How can I get better at seeing him in others?

The lessons seem pretty clear too:

  • We should find and see Jesus in those in need.
  • Jesus is the one we are really serving; and
  • If we serve and respond to those in need we’ll gain a reward for ourselves and avoid a punishment.

Here’s the problem with those questions and lessons. The hungry, the thirsty, the stranger, the naked, the sick, the imprisoned, are forgotten, overlooked, or used as a means to an end. That’s business as usual. Nothing changes and we continue to live in an economy of rewards and punishments.

What if we are asking the wrong questions and learning the wrong lessons? What if we are misreading this gospel?

Maybe this text is less about my future reward or punishment, and more about the present needs of those around me. Maybe it’s less about what will happen to me in the future and more about what is happening to others today.

Rereading the Text

What if it doesn’t matter whether we see Jesus in those in need? Is seeing Jesus in another really the reason we should respond to her or his needs? Maybe Jesus is not the prerequisite or condition that determines what we do and do not do but the voice of one calling, asking, hoping, praying for us to reach out and do something.

Maybe there is only one reason to respond to those in need. Because they are in need.

“The hungry were hungry, and the sick were sick, and the imprisoned were imprisoned. Period. Enough said.” (John D. Caputo, What to Believe? Twelve Brief Lessons in Radical Theology (New York: Columbia University Press, 2023), 162.)

The righteous did not ask why the hungry were hungry, where the stranger was from, or what the imprisoned had done. Instead, they fed, welcomed, and visited without questions or conditions.

“The righteous undertook these works of mercy without knowing that these were the Lord’s own.” (Ibid.) Those in need were not a means to anything. They were not an investment by which the righteous expected a return or a reward. The righteous “responded unconditionally, without reserve, without why.” (Ibid. 163)

And what if that’s how we lived every day, every where, and with everyone? What would that take?

  • Who is hungry? Give them something to eat.
  • Who is thirsty? Give them something to drink.
  • Who is a stranger? Welcome them.
  • Who is naked? Give them some clothes.
  • Who is sick? Care for them.
  • Who is imprisoned? Visit them.

Why? Because.

Because why? Because they are hungry. Because they are thirsty. Because they are a stranger. Because they are naked. Because they are sick. Because they are imprisoned. Because they are in need.

That is the kingdom. And whether the kingdom comes is up to you and me.

The kingdom of God is not a reward for works of mercy and justice. The kingdom of God is the works of mercy and justice. (Ibid.)

Either we give the kingdom existence here and now or we don’t.

Which will it be?

____________________
Image Credit: Photo by Deski Jayantoro on Unsplash.

© Michael K. Marsh and Interrupting the Silence, 2009-2026, all rights reserved.

Subscribe to receive new posts by email.

Share and like this post:

One response to “Because They Are In Need – A Reflection On Matthew 25:31-46”

  1. Ann Fraser Avatar
    Ann Fraser

    Thanks, Mike. I love the clarity that works of mercy IS the kingdom. Peace to you today!

Leave a Reply