By Another Road – An Epiphany Reflection On Matthew 2:1-12

Published by

on

A couple of weeks ago I had a dream that has stuck with me, asking for some attention and consideration. 

Toward the end of the dream, I decide to go home. The road home is on the other side of a small hill. I’m on my bike and when I get to the top of the hill I see that the road ahead of me has been completely destroyed. Military planes are flying low, bombing, and shooting along the road. I cannot go home on that road. While I’m standing there looking at the road a group of cyclists and a few cars speed past me, go down the hill, and turn right into a dark forest. The dream ends.  

It’s not a surprising dream. It highlights and holds before me what I already know. I am at a point in my life when I cannot continue traveling the same road. I’ve retired and moved to a new house in a new town. My life has changed. I have changed. The context, opportunities, and challenges of my life have changed. And I must find a new road, a different way of getting home. 

I suspect that happens to all of us at some point in our lives, probably more than once. Life changes. Circumstances change. Things happen. Plans don’t work out. And the usual and familiar road can no longer take us where we want or need to go. Desires, needs, interests, resources, or opportunities have changed. The old ways no longer work. We have to travel a different road.

Maybe you know what I’m talking about. Maybe that’s where you are today. Maybe you’re having to find a different road. How do we find that other road and what guides us in those times? 

As I reflect on my dream I recall the journey of the wise men in the Epiphany story (Matthew 2:1-12). “They left for their own country by another road” (Matthew 2:12). The road that brought them to Jerusalem could not take them home. They had to find a different road, a new way home. 

And the thing that strikes me about that is that it wasn’t a star that put them on that other road. It was what I am calling an anti-star.

Here’s what I mean by that. What guides the wise men to a new road, a different road, is the very opposite of the star that led them to Jerusalem and then on to Bethlehem. Herod is the anti-star. 

“Having been warned in a dream not to return to Herod, [the wise men] left for their own country by another road” (Matthew 2:12).

Herod is the opposite of everything that was reflected in the light of the star that originally led the wise men to the place where Jesus was. He was a tyrannical and authoritarian king who “rose to power largely through his father’s good relations with Julius Caesar.” He was known for colossal building projects. He was despotic, brutal, and violent, even executing some of his own family. He “used secret police to monitor and report the feelings of the general populace toward him. He sought to prohibit protests, and had opponents removed by force.” (Wikipedia) He was afraid (Matthew 2:3). He slaughtered the innocent (Matthew 2:16) and executed John the Baptist (Matthew 14:10).

Herod is a dark star, a fallen star, the anti-star about which the wise men were “warned in a dream.” Because of him they found another road to their own country. 

There are stars and there are anti-stars and both guide us. One calls us more deeply into who and how we want to be. One gives and values life. The other repels us from what takes and diminishes life. We look at the other and say, “That’s not who or how I want to be,” and we find another road home. 

So let me ask you this: Who or what are the stars and the anti-stars in your life these days? Who or what are they in the life of this country? In what ways might they be guiding, asking, or pushing us to take a different road, whether personally or nationally? 

Neither my dream nor the Epiphany story tells me which road to take. They simply highlight that it’s time for me to choose a different road. Maybe that’s true for you. For America. 

What do you think? What would it mean for you, me, America to take a different road?

____________________
Image Credit: Photo by Colin Lloyd on Unsplash.

© Michael K. Marsh and Interrupting the Silence, 2009-2026, all rights reserved.

12 responses to “By Another Road – An Epiphany Reflection On Matthew 2:1-12”

  1. Bob Avatar

    The best road to walk is the road to Emmaus with Jesus. Walking with Him will bring us home safely.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Michael K. Marsh Avatar

      Yes, but it sure seems like a long, rough and treacherous road these.

      Peace be with you,
      Mike

      Like

  2. Nancy Coon Avatar
    Nancy Coon

    Thanks, Mike for Words of Wisdom from you.

    See you soon and look forward to our Seminarians Retreat.

    Blessings and Love to you and Family.

    Faithfully, Nancy+

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Michael K. Marsh Avatar

      Thank you Nancy. I hope all is well for you.

      God’s peace be with you,
      Mike

      Like

  3. Arabella Norton Avatar
    Arabella Norton

    Dear Fr Mike

    Your reflections are so helpful and thank you for continuing to share them in your retirement. I pray that your path in this next stage of your life may become clearer to you but please know what a huge help your thoughts are for me ( in England) and I’m sure for many others around the world too. Please keep them coming! And maybe they can be turned into a book?

    With every best wish for a blessed Epiphany season.

    Arabella Norton

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Michael K. Marsh Avatar

      Arabella, thank you so much for your prayers, encouragement, and support. I am grateful.

      God’s peace be with you,
      Mike

      Like

  4. Ros Box Avatar
    Ros Box

    Thank you Fr Mike for these thoughts. As our Rectory is retiring this year, they are very apt for him – your words have been forwarded on to him. Here in Scotland, our hearts are so sad for the news coming from America – our prayers are with and for all who are standing against the divisive culture that is plaguing your country – Ros

    Liked by 1 person

    1. erikamorck Avatar

      Ros- thank you for keeping my country and her people in your prayers. We surely need a Star of Light right now -to lead us on a road worthy of our founding 250 years ago and our Lord. Blessings to you.

      Liked by 1 person

    2. Michael K. Marsh Avatar

      Ros, thank you for your prayers and presence. They are much needed and appreciated. blessing on your priest’s retirement and you all as you make the transition to your next priest.

      God’s peace be with you,
      Mike

      Like

  5. politeobject7ccb0b9ad6 Avatar
    politeobject7ccb0b9ad6

    Being a priest, a shepherd, a pastoral carer is almost all consuming; and suddenly leaving it behind is almost having to reinvent oneself – creating a new way of being. Since the end of 2023 I have been on that journey too. My spiritual director told me to be still and rest, and my path would become clear in time. What I have learned is that the way forward has not been fast, nor blindingly clear; and that it may be necessary to allow the person, who has conformed to the Church’s rituals and traditions for many years, to slowly emerge from that familiar role, and see who I am without all that. It’s hard to let go and step into the dark forest!

    I’m so glad you are still reflecting and writing your wise words. They help me immensely. My thoughts and prayers are with you as you begin to negotiate this next stage of your journey in your own life and what is happening in your country at present.

    Blessings,

    Margaret Priest

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Michael K. Marsh Avatar

      Margaret, yes, there is very real sense of finding oneself again. Thank you for sharing your experience and wisdom. Emerging form teh familiar is a great way to describe it. Thank you for your prayers and good wishes.

      God’s peace be with you,
      Mike

      Like

      1. politeobject7ccb0b9ad6 Avatar
        politeobject7ccb0b9ad6

        Hi Mike,

        I had trouble signing in when I wrote that response, and I obviously didn’t finish!

        My real name is Marilyn Obersby and I have emailed you a few times under that name. Margaret Priest is a name I use for a few websites I don’t want my real name to appear on. I really find a lot to reflect on in your sermons, and feel for your present struggles under a Trump administration.

        I have been doing a lot of reading – my own spirituality and ancestry is Celtic – and I have also re-read Searching for Sophia, an old but definitely relevant book for the Church and society at this time. As I read I became angry all over again about the imbalance in the world, which has caused such suffering and oppression; and which the Christian Church and most religions have helped cause and perpetuate with the image of a male god and the inferiority of the female half, not only of the human race, but of all creation. I have struggled to remain in the Church, especially to remain a priest, and am really only still there because I believe my own truth needs to be a part of my own faith community; and I love the people. I still remember the occasion in the early 90’s, when our vicar changed all the pronouns and names for God in the Eucharistic liturgy to feminine ones. There was an instant outcry from the men, who said they felt not included. Dick then said, that’s how half the human race may feel when taking part in the liturgy of the Church – not included. It gave rise to a lot of reflection in our parish. But of course the Church, and God, is still male, and the power structures of the world are male, so not much changes. I once jokingly said to someone I want to be in the part of heaven where the women can make their own decisions free of men’s dictates and biases and ways of seeing the world:)

        One book I am presently reading by Margaret Silf is called Landscapes of Prayer, taking different geographical settings and reflecting on the spiritual journey through them. Last night I read about the cave, referencing the still small voice and why we enter a cave, what it means. I have been seeing my journey as being in a bit of a wilderness, but after reading her words last night, I realise I’m in a cave, safe, sheltered, anxious and frustrated, yet waiting to hear the voice that will speak to me and draw me out into that new beginning whatever that may be. It will have to be something that enables me to live with the integrity of how I know God to be in my life, because otherwise I am still just conforming to the picture of God and reality the Church represents.

        I’m trying to live out my old age with ‘wisdom and grace’ – the title of another book I’ve read recently, that my spiritual director recommended. Meanwhile, having a Celtic way of seeing creation and God is my anchor and my reality. John Philip Newell’s ‘The Great Search’, which I’m also currently reading, is expressing just how I feel and see life – a great affirmation for me.

        I’ve no idea where we’re heading as the human race, but I do live with hope, not necessarily optimism, because our free choice can bring everything to the brink of extinction, but hope because this is God’s creation and we are all made in God’s image and are indwelt by God’s Spirit; and ultimately it is God who holds all Creation in being; and it is God who will ultimately decide the future and fate of us all and of our beautiful planet, as well as every part of Creation.

        Thank you for your honest, thoughtful wrestling with matters of faith and life. Your reflections have been and continue to be a bright light in my faith journey over these past few years.

        Blessings on your faith journey as you work out your next steps,

        Marilyn Obersby, mostly retired Anglican priest, Gippsland diocese, Australia.

        Like

Leave a reply to Michael K. Marsh Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.