The Star Knows The Way – An Epiphany Sermon On Matthew 2:1-12

Since the start of the new year Cyndy and I have returned to some familiar questions and conversations about our lives individually and as a couple. Where are we headed? Where is her life going? Where is my life going? What are we really after? I wouldn’t be surprised if you’ve asked or wondered about the same things in your life. 

I’m also asking those questions in regard to our parish and the upcoming annual meeting. Where is St. Philip’s going in 2022? Nearly two years into the pandemic and on the first anniversary of the attack on our nation’s capitol I can’t help but wonder where our county is headed in this new year. 

What kind of new year questions are you asking about your life and future? And how’s that going for you?

I’ve got to be honest with you, I’m struggling with those questions and conversations. The answers aren’t as clear today as when I was younger, or even just a few years ago, and the questions feel more difficult. I keep waiting for a flash of insight, an epiphany, an “Aha, I got it,” but it’s not coming. 

I’m finding those conversations and questions all end in the same way, with me saying, “I don’t know, I just don’t know anymore.” 

And I don’t think I’m the only one who doesn’t know. Haven’t there been times when you didn’t know where your life was going, times when you just weren’t sure where you were headed? 

I think about the wise men in today’s gospel (Matthew 2:1-12) and wonder if they asked similar questions or had similar conversations about where they were headed. They didn’t know where they were going the day they left home. They didn’t know where they would be the next day, the next week, or six months later. They couldn’t see their destination any more than I can see the destination of my life, my marriage, this parish, or our country.

Here’s the thing that strikes me about the journey of the wise men. They did not know their destination until they arrived. That seems pretty obvious right now, but I often forget or overlook that. And what if that’s true for you and me as well? What if we don’t know our destination until we arrive. No wonder my questions and conversations don’t get me anywhere. No wonder they all end the same way. No wonder I don’t know.

But maybe we don’t need to know and maybe the wise men didn’t either. In one of her letters Emily Dickinson writes this:

“The sailor cannot see the North, but knows the needle can.”

That sure fits today’s gospel. The wise men cannot see the child or Bethlehem, but they know the star can. Maybe we can never see the destination, we can only follow the star.

What stars are you following these days? What’s the compass in your life? 

Let me give you some examples of what I mean. I’m asking about things like this:

  • The values and qualities that direct and guide your life; 
  • The wise women and men whose advice and counsel you seek and trust; 
  • The principles and standards to which you hold yourself accountable; 
  • The scriptures and prayers that shape and form your life; 
  • The deep longings, desires, and callings that energize and move your life forward; 
  • The silence, stillness, and solitude, by which you gain clarity;
  • The people and relationships that orient your life; and 
  • The practices by which you maintain your integrity and authenticity. 

What if those are the light of Epiphany in each of our lives? And what if it’s not just one star but a whole constellation giving shape and direction to our lives? And what if we were less concerned about where we are going and more concerned about the way we are going?

I can’t tell you where my life, my marriage, this parish, or our country are going but I can tell you the way I want to go. I can tell you the stars I want to follow.

I want to go by way of love, intimacy, and vulnerability. I want to go by way justice, truth, and honesty. I want to go by way of compassion, inclusion, welcome, and care for others. I want to go by way of integrity and authenticity. I want to go by way of gratitude and forgiveness. 

What about you? What stars do you want to follow? By what ways do you want to go? 

Here’s the paradox in today’s gospel. The wise men did not know their destination, but they knew the way. They knew which star to follow. And that was enough. That was all they needed to know. They followed the star and it took them exactly where they needed to go. Why would it be any different for us?

The star knows the way.

Epiphany Links:
+ What About The Fourth Wise Man?
+ House Blessing With Chalk, Epiphany 2022
+ Epiphany Proclamation Of Easter 2022


  1. My first response to your question is “wandering in the desert”. But we all know it is a journey and a pilgrimage, and yes, we can’t really plan, and we are just doing the days as best we can. But we are hopefully holding on to the hand of the God who made us and is walking with us. Thanks for all your wonderful reflections, Martina

    Liked by 1 person

      1. Here is a poem for that feeling: by Pat Mayne Ellis,
        Awash in Tiny Diamonds

        By Pat Mayne Ellis, from Exit 13, No. 2 Autumn/Winter © 1989
Scientists find universe awash in tiny diamonds
        But haven’t we always known?
The shimmer of trees, the shaking of flames
every cloud lined with something
clean water sings
right to the belly
scouring us with its purity
it too is awash with diamonds
        “so small that trillions could rest
on the head of a pin”
        It is not unwise then to say
that the air is hung close with diamonds
that we breathe diamond
our lungs hoarding, exchanging
our blood sowing them rich and thick
along every course it takes
Does this explain
why some of us are so hard
why some of us shine
why we are all precious
        that we are awash in creation
spumed with diamonds
shot through with beauty
that survived the death of stars

        By Pat Mayne Ellis,  from “Cries of the Sprit,” Beacon Press, Boston, © 1991

        Liked by 1 person

  2. Father Mike, thank you for sharing this epiphany!! I don’t feel so alone in my wandering and wondering and “just not knowing” Martin Luther said something along the lines of “I know not the way God leads me, but well do I know my Guide!” I am holding onto this for the unknown road ahead. Blessings on you way!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Erika, those are good words from Luther. Thanks for sharing them. It seems like much of life is traveling “the unknown road.” May you have bright stars and good companion to guide and accompany you.

      Peace be with you,

      Liked by 1 person

  3. I stumble into your blog from time to time and find kindred spirits hanging out here. Your reflection reminds me of a poem I wrote a few years ago, before Jan.6 became the defining meme that it is. It means more to me today in light of your reflection, Mike, than it did then. Thank you. Thank you for holding space for silence.

    What Is the Knocking?

    It is the three strange angels. Admit them. Admit them.
    — D. H. Lawrence

    A golden-fronted woodpecker raps on the eaves
    above the door early this morning,
    forsaking the acres of oaks just beyond,
    searching instead for whatever sustenance
    might lie dormant in the cedar beams.
    It is the sixth of January, the Epiphany,
    and I wonder if the caller at my door
    might be one of the Magi,
    clutching that gold to his chest,
    lost on the way to Bethlehem,
    a couple of thousand years late,
    many thousand miles off track,
    having misread the antiquated GPS
    of a certain star.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you for this reminder, Mike. I needed it just this minute because I am responding to a desperate teenager, encouraging her to try poetry. We are all magi, aren’t we? Peace.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: