God Insists – An Epiphany Sermon On Matthew 2:1-12

Epiphany, Feast of the Epiphany, Matthew 2:1-12, Sermon, Star of Bethlehem
Star of Bethlehem by Waldemar Flaig - http://waldemarflaig.com/, Public Domain, Wikimedia Commons https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=14822506

The Epiphany – Matthew 2:1-12

I going to tell you about an epiphany that happened yesterday, here at St. Philip’s. It’s a bit different from the usual story we think of when we hear the word epiphany. It’s not about a star, the magi, gold, frankincense, or myrrh like we heard about in today’s gospel (Mt. 2:1-12). But then those aren’t really the point of today’s gospel either. The story I am going to tell you, just like the one in today’s gospel, reveals the divine presence, Emmanuel, God with us. 

Epiphany, Feast of the Epiphany, Matthew 2:1-12, Sermon, Star of Bethlehem
Star of Bethlehem by Waldemar Flaig, Public Domain, Wikimedia Commons 

I was with about twenty or twenty-five friends and family members of Phyllis. We had gathered in the columbarium for her committal; to say the prayers that would accompany her ashes being placed in the columbarium. One of her daughters was going to place the container in the columbarium. About half way through the liturgy I uncovered the container of ashes. The daughter picked up the container and just held it for a moment. Then she kissed it. She turned and held the container for her dad and sisters to kiss. And they did. Then she looked at me and asked, “Is this ok?” “Perfect,” I said. She went and stood before each person there, holding the container for them to kiss. Everyone offered a kiss. We had not discussed or planned for that. She was simply responding to the insistence of the moment. The star had shown itself and we were following. It was an epiphany.

I am not talking about epiphany in the usual sense of having a flash of insight or a sudden recognition. I don’t think that’s what today’s gospel or this Feast of the Epiphany are about. I’ve come to believe that we don’t have epiphanies but that they have us. That’s why the magi followed the star. Something had claimed and called them. Something had ahold of them. Epiphanies are not so much those moments when we say, “Aha, I’ve got it!” They are, rather, moments when we say, “Aha, it’s got me!” 

That’s what happened yesterday in the columbarium. “It” got us. I can’t exactly tell you or explain what that “it” is. Maybe the most and best I can say is that “it” is whatever is happening in that moment in the name of God. “It” could be love, justice, forgiveness, compassion, beauty, joy, generosity, resurrection, strength, consolation, or a thousand other possibilities. The “it” of epiphany is not so much a thing or being – God out there somewhere, a supernatural being pushing buttons and pulling strings. The “it” of epiphany is an action or happening that just arises. The “it” that gets us is more verb than noun.

“It” is God’s insistence in and on us. “It” is the continuing yes of Christmas. “It” is God’s soliciting, luring, inviting, evoking, wooing, asking a response from us. Yesterday in the columbarium “it” was resurrection evoking and calling forth the kiss of life. What is “it” for you today? How and what is God insisting in your life?

Whatever God’s insisting for you might be, whatever the “it” is in your life, “it” is God desiring, maybe even needing, to be seen, known, experienced by you. Epiphany happens at the intersection of God’s insistence and our response, and it requires both. A star that is not seen and followed is just another luminous ball of gas. A journey that has no guiding star is just another road trip. You and I give existence to God’s insistence through our actions, our words, our lives. 

Mary gave existence to God’s insistence by saying, “Let it be with me according to your word.” The shepherds responded to God insistence by going “to Bethlehem to see this thing that has taken place.” In today’s gospel the magi say, “We observed his star at its rising, and have come to pay him homage.” The women at the empty tomb responded to God’s insistence by telling the disciples the good news. God is always insisting in our lives. The insisting of God happens in the ordinary conditions and everyday circumstances of our lives. 

Tell me about that one you love, that love that is beyond your ability to describe or express with words. You don’t know why you love. You only know that you love. And it’s a love that is deeper than and beyond what you feel. You can’t explain it. You only know that you will continue to give yourself to him or her “for better for worse, for richer for poorer, in sickness and in health, to love and cherish until [you] are parted by death.” In that self-giving each day is an epiphany in which you are giving existence to God’s insistence.

Do you remember the very first time you held your child or grandchild? You caressed, you kissed, you cooed, your cuddled, your radiated. Something happened. Your heart was opened and you experienced and participated in the beauty and miracle of life. You knew that somehow you were holding the sacred, the holy, the miraculous, in your hands. It was a moment of epiphany and you gave existence to God’s insistence. 

Think about one of those days when nothing special happened but everything was just right. Nothing was missing. Nothing was lacking. There was a fullness and satisfaction and you couldn’t explain why. You didn’t know. You only knew that you didn’t want the day to end and you thought or said to yourself, “My God, this is the perfect day. Thank you.” In that prayer you gave existence to God’s insistence. 

You have probably had days you thought you would never get through; an overwhelming situation, a divorce, the loss of a job, the death of a loved one. You couldn’t imagine getting through another day or week let alone a year. You didn’t know how you would do it or if you even could. But you did. You hoped against hope and you continued to show up. You were giving existence to God’s insistence.

Have you ever told someone something about your life that you had never told anyone else before? It was one of those secrets that was wrapped in shame, guilt, or embarrassment and it kept you bound to the past. That other person listened without judgment. He or she didn’t laugh, condemn, or ridicule. They honored and respected you. As you talked a way forward opened up, a way you never expected or thought possible, and you knew that you were moving to a new place in your life. That was an epiphany in which God’s insistence was given existence. 

How about one of those times when something begins to stir in you, a deep longing, a passion? Maybe it’s a concern for others, an expression of compassion, speaking out for justice, feeding the hungry. Maybe it’s a vocational calling. You feel it as an energy or drive. You don’t know where it will take you and you’re not exactly sure what you will do. But you respond. You act. That’s an epiphany in which you are giving existence to God’s insistence. 

The star of God’s insistence is always rising in our lives. It’s happening all the time. There is not a one of you here today in whom God is not insisting and hoping for a response. 

What in the name of God is happening in your life today? I don’t know what “it” is for you today, but I know this. There is a rising star waiting to be observed and followed. 

God insists, and the rest is up to us.

This sermon was inspired by John D. Caputo’s Hoping Against Hope: Confessions of a Postmodern Pilgrim, 114-122. 


  1. I’m GLAD YOU LISTENED to the Holy Spirit, in the Service of Commital, BUT even more in sharing this Message!!! Thank you!!! With Much Love, in Christ Jesus, A Servant of The Most High God, The Rev. Chet Thompson Romans1:16-17; Jeremiah 29:11-14   “Thus says the LORD: Remember not the events of the past, the things of long ago consider not; see, I am doing something new!  Now it springs forth, do you not perceive it?”  -Isaiah 43:18-19

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Discovering this message in my email today was an epiphany for me. Few are willing to speak so generously and intimately about those real life experiences when we yield to the moments God is insisting.
    Old age is teaching me how extraordinary simple moments are…sitting here savoring your gift of words from the heart. It makes me want to declare everything a miracle…even the pain and struggles.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Elizabeth, yes, either everything is a miracle or nothing is. And, like you, I am finding that more and more to be in the simple moments. I wonder how many miracles I’ve missed because I was looking for something extraordinary and spectacular.

      Epiphany blessings to you,


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: