Irreparable Loss

Published by

on

Poetry, Death, Suffering, Loss, Resurrection, Salvation, Lazarus, John Caputo, Death of a Child, John 11:1-44
Angel of Grief by Carptrash, Wikipedia, CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia Commons

Some losses are irreparable.
The time is ruined.
The suffering cannot be redeemed.

There is no gain from this pain,
no view long enough to eventually say, “It was worth it,”
nothing that can compensate for what has been taken.

And that’s okay.
I do not want a salary for my suffering,
I want salvation from it.

This irreparable loss,
this ruined time,
this unredeemable suffering,
expose finitude –
mine and God’s.

When has God ever turned back time or undone the past?
In the face of grief and sorrow God is weak and powerless.
Where is the Omni in that Potent?

Either God cannot or God simply chooses not to.

If those are my choices, I choose the weak God.
That’s the God who knows me best.
That’s the God who knows my finitude before loss, suffering, death.
That’s the God whose tears mingle with mine.
That’s the God whose heart breaks with mine.

“And Jesus wept,”
just like me.

I would rather believe in a God who cannot undo my past
than a God who can but chooses not to.
I no longer have much room or need for the Omnipotent God.

I don’t want magic, I want a miracle.
“Magic is an illusory strong force,”
turning back time, undoing the past,
“a miracle is a genuine but weak force of God,”
a new birth, a new beginning, a new day.

“Lazarus, come out!”

I cannot escape my past,
but I can be unbound.
I can enter a new time,
the time of salvation.

“Unbind him, and let him go.”


This poem is based on and inspired by John Caputo’s The Weakness of God – A Theology of the Event (Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press, 2006), 236-244.

© Michael K. Marsh and Interrupting the Silence, 2009-2025, all rights reserved.

9 responses to “Irreparable Loss”

  1. Barbara Edwards Avatar
    Barbara Edwards

    My words fail me. The pain, truth and beauty of your poem have touched the depths of my heart as my heart reaches out to you and Cyndy with love and friendship.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Michael K. Marsh Avatar

      Barbara, thank you so much for your large and gentle heart. Cyndy and I are grateful for you friendship and presence in our lives.

      God’s peace be with you,
      Mike+

      Like

  2. Beverly Heyen Avatar
    Beverly Heyen

    Mike, thank you for sharing. It spoke to my heart and I appreciate the way you and Cyndy give comfort to those who have suffered your similar loss.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Michael K. Marsh Avatar

      Beverly, I know that you know. We walk this path together. May you know God’s strength, consolation, and unbinding your life.

      Peace be with you,
      Mike+

      Like

  3. texsc Avatar

    Mike, the best I can do with this is is to draw on the Fatherhood of God. On the human level, we give birth to our sons or daughters and guide them closely up to a point, but at that point, they go beyond our control and do things we wish they wouldn’t do, but if they are free, we cannot guide and guard every move they make. On a higher level, it helps me to think of God in similar terms as Our Heavenly Father. That may not satisfy other people, and I know the analogy breaks down. But that usually helps me . . . to a point.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Michael K. Marsh Avatar

      Thank you Lawrence. Love and freedom always go together and there is a certain powerlessness in that, for us and for God.

      Peace be with you,
      Mike+

      Like

  4. A New Day, A New Life – A Sermon On Mark 10:17-31 – Interrupting the Silence Avatar

    […] your could carry, when things were spinning out of control, when grief was strangling your soul, when the loss was irreparable and the time was ruined, when the life your were living was not the life you desired. Maybe some of you are experiencing […]

    Like

  5. On Days Like This – A Sermon On John 18:1-19:42 For Good Friday – Interrupting the Silence Avatar

    […] of this day long enough to eventually say, “It was worth it.” You know as well as I do that some losses are irreparable. The time is ruined. The suffering cannot be […]

    Like

  6. Living The Unbearable In Uvalde – A Sermon On John 16:12-15 – Interrupting the Silence Avatar

    […] Some losses are irreparable. There is nothing to be gained from the pain. There is no view long enough to eventually say, “It was worth it.” Nothing can compensate for what has been taken.  […]

    Like

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.